top of page

Culinary Quest: Tips for Choosing Your Wedding Caterer

Updated: Jun 22

Choosing a wedding caterer can be one of the most enjoyable aspects of wedding planning and provides an opportunity to consider how your theme might carry through to your food choices. Will you select more traditional favorites, or go with something bold and innovative? You're curating a menu that reflects your tastes, preferences, and overarching vision for the wedding. Another reason to love it? The process also lets you engage in tastings and discover culinary delights that will add a unique touch to your celebration. The tastings can be an event in themselves, and don't forget, you'll want to include your wine pairings for the overall effect.

Get the Vista 222 Catering Vendor Worksheet:

Vista 222 Caterer Selection Worksheet
Download PDF • 1.97MB

Vendor Relationships  - Check to see if your potential caterer has established relationships with your venue and other vendors. (Vista 222 has a suggested vendor list we can provide during planning!) This can streamline coordination and logistics on the big day. If your caterer has worked at your venue before, ask for feedback on their experience. They might have valuable insights on the best setup and flow for your event. Good vendor relationships can lead to a more seamless and stress-free wedding day.


Helpful Hint: Ask your venue coordinator for feedback on the caterers they have worked with. They can offer practical advice on who handles the venue logistics well.


Research and Reviews - Reading reviews can help you identify consistent issues or praises that give you a clear picture of what to expect. Additionally, don't hesitate to ask friends and family for recommendations based on their experiences. Seeking feedback from those you trust can provide valuable insights into the quality of service and overall experience with different caterers.

Helpful Hint: When reading reviews, pay attention to specific details mentioned repeatedly, as they can indicate consistent strengths or weaknesses of a caterer.


References and Portfolio - Ask for references from past clients and a portfolio of previous events. This gives you a sense of their style and reliability. Contact at least three references and ask specific questions about punctuality, professionalism, and any unexpected challenges during their events. Reviewing a portfolio can inspire ideas for your wedding and assure you of the caterer's capabilities.


Helpful Hint: When reviewing portfolios, look for diversity in the types of events and menus they have handled to ensure they can meet your specific needs.


Tasting Sessions - Schedule tasting sessions with a few top choices. This allows you to sample their dishes and see how well they can cater to your taste preferences and dietary needs. Bring a trusted friend or family member to the tasting sessions for a second opinion. Sometimes, a different palate can provide valuable insights and help you make a more informed decision. Pay attention not just to taste but also to presentation and service.

Helpful Hint: Take notes during the tasting sessions on not just the flavors, but also on the presentation and service, so you can compare caterers later.

Budget Considerations - Clearly define your budget before meeting caterers. Ask for detailed quotes and understand what's included (e.g., service fees, rentals, gratuities). Request an itemized breakdown of costs to understand what you're paying for. This can help in making adjustments without compromising the quality of service. Remember to account for potential hidden fees and ensure everything fits within your overall wedding budget.

Helpful Hint: Consider setting aside a small contingency fund within your budget for any unexpected expenses that might arise.

Menu Flexibility - Discuss the caterer's flexibility in menu options and how they accommodate dietary restrictions, cultural preferences, and personal tastes. Before meeting with caterers, create a list of must-have dishes and any specific dietary requirements. This ensures you don't forget anything important during discussions and helps the caterer understand your vision and needs. Flexibility can be a key factor in choosing the right caterer.

Helpful Hint: When discussing flexibility, ask if the caterer can provide alternative options for guests with dietary restrictions, ensuring everyone can enjoy the meal.

Service Style -Decide on the type of service you want - buffet, plated dinner, family-style, or food stations. Each has its pros and cons in terms of cost, formality, and guest experience. Consider your venue's layout and space when deciding on service style. For instance, food stations might work better in a spacious area, while a plated dinner suits more formal, seated settings. The service style should complement your wedding's atmosphere and your guests' comfort.

Helpful Hint: Think about the flow of the event and how the service style will impact guest movement and interaction during the reception.

Customization: Look for caterers who offer customizable menus. Personal touches, like a signature cocktail or a dish from your first date, can make your menu unique and memorable. Ask if the caterer can incorporate a family recipe or a dish with sentimental value. This adds a personal touch to your wedding menu and makes the meal more meaningful for you and your guests. Customization can elevate the dining experience and reflect your personal style.

Helpful Hint: Provide the caterer with any family recipes or special dish ideas well in advance.

Seasonal and Local Ingredients: Inquire if the caterer uses seasonal and locally sourced ingredients. This can ensure fresher, more flavorful dishes and support local businesses. Request a sample seasonal menu to get an idea of what dishes might be available during your wedding month. This can also help you visualize the final spread. Seasonal menus often bring out the best flavors and make your wedding meal stand out.

Helpful Hint: Ask the caterer how they handle ingredient substitutions in case a particular seasonal item is not available at the time of your wedding.

Contract Details Ensure the contract includes all details: menu items, number of servings, service times, staff-to-guest ratio, and policies on leftovers. Before signing the contract, double-check for any hidden fees or clauses. Make sure you understand the cancellation policy and any conditions for changes in the guest count or menu. A detailed and clear contract protects both you and the caterer and helps avoid misunderstandings.

Helpful Hint: Review the contract well, and don't hesitate to ask for clarification on any unclear or ambiguous terms.


Remember, this process is about finding what suits your preferences and reflects the essence of your celebration. Embrace the opportunity to explore different options, ask questions, and choose the things that resonate with your vision. With careful planning and thoughtful consideration, you'll create a menu that adds to the joy and magic of your wedding day.



  • White Facebook Icon
  • White Instagram Icon
bottom of page